Travel reviews by Mr I from Combs
Review Distribution
Total number of trips
1
Countries visited
2
Lodges stayed in
11
Excursions taken
0
My Dec 2007 trip
Namibia and 1 other country between 5 Dec 2007 and 6 Jan 2008
"Very good."
Arranged By Tracy Lederer
Ghaub Guest Farm
"Ghaub Guest Farm review"
2 nights
Arrived
6 Dec 2007
Good
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Good
Location
Excellent
Service
Good
Activities
Average
Rooms
Good
Food
Good
Facilities
Average
Nxamaseri Lodge
"Nxamaseri Lodge review"
3 nights
Arrived
8 Dec 2007
"Journey to the lodge made stressful. Instructions from Expert Africa to phone Lodge in the morning proved difficult and in fact we could not make contact until we reached border crossing where a most helpful Botswana official contacted them.
We had tried all day, from garages, other lodges , mobiles etc. adding at least an hour onto our journey. Sarah and Darren are new owners and said they had been in but I think it must have been problems with lines.
Better to arrange a time and place to meet at time of booking or just before departure.. and then contact ONLY if there is a problem.
However we enjoyed our stay. The food and company was excellent and the birds exceptional. The only comment would be it would be good to have a boat with a cover.. (this was also a problem at Ichingo and Camp Kwando when it rained ???? )"
We had tried all day, from garages, other lodges , mobiles etc. adding at least an hour onto our journey. Sarah and Darren are new owners and said they had been in but I think it must have been problems with lines.
Better to arrange a time and place to meet at time of booking or just before departure.. and then contact ONLY if there is a problem.
However we enjoyed our stay. The food and company was excellent and the birds exceptional. The only comment would be it would be good to have a boat with a cover.. (this was also a problem at Ichingo and Camp Kwando when it rained ???? )"
Good
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Good
Location
Excellent
Service
Excellent
Activities
Excellent
Rooms
Good
Food
Excellent
Facilities
Good
Feedback response
We very much appreciate these travellers’ comments and will certainly inform future travellers of an approximate meeting time. In the past we have spent time looking at the best possible way of making the arrangement for getting to Nxamaseri as efficient as possible. In general these work well however unfortunately in this instant, this was not the case - which is of no consolation to these travellers but is hopefully reassuring for those who plan to visit in the future.
Ndhovu Safari Lodge
"Excellent host and hippos."
1 night
Arrived
11 Dec 2007
"Warm welcome. Great host. Wonderful evening boat trip. Delicious food. Comfortable tent with amazing views of hippos.
Wished we had booked for 2 or three nights."
Wished we had booked for 2 or three nights."
Excellent
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Excellent
Location
Excellent
Service
Excellent
Activities
Excellent
Rooms
Excellent
Food
Excellent
Facilities
Good
Ichingo Chobe River Lodge
"Ichingo Chobe Lodge review"
3 nights
Arrived
12 Dec 2007
"Again we felt it would have been better for instructions to advise us to meet at the fromt of the Immigration Office rather than at the wharf. It was raining cats and dogs. The boat was late because of lightening and storm and we had no indication of what or who to look out for and had it not been for a helpful guide from the Chobe Safari Lodge we would have thought they had forgotten about us. No means of contact as mobiles not getting through. There was no cover on the boat and we were soaked along with our luggage.
Why not meet the boat at Chobe Safari Lodge after you have gone through procedures at immigration ? HOWEVER..
Once we arrived....
The welcome was good and we enjoyed our stay."
Why not meet the boat at Chobe Safari Lodge after you have gone through procedures at immigration ? HOWEVER..
Once we arrived....
The welcome was good and we enjoyed our stay."
Good
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Good
Location
Good
Service
Excellent
Activities
Good
Rooms
Good
Food
Excellent
Facilities
Good
Camp Kwando
"NICE CAMP. PITY ABOUT THE MANAGEMENT."
2 nights
Arrived
15 Dec 2007
"We felt we were interupting the managements holiday !! The "local black" staff were brilliant. David the guide and the girls etc. The 4 "Managers" 3 guys and a girl were not interested. Only Ely the guide introduced himself, took us a 2 hour boat trip...very informative but smoked all the way !! Not usual when guiding guests...Really strange behaviour by these 4. We had to go and find them and ask everything..time of dinner etc. When we went to have a drink and dinner they sat together drinking, just said Hi and then carried on with their chat. We had no drink, nowhere visible to sit only at a dining table as they were at the only "lounge table" and only 4 chairs.
Even when I went to ask about a drink they never got up, just called a girl from the kitchen so we sat at one of the tables set for dinner and had an early night. They obviously ate later at the other table..Same thing on the second night after our trip out with David. He walks for 3 hrs. to be at work for 8am. and leaves at 5 pm. for his 3 hr. walk home ! Some of the girls also have over an hours walk to and from the camp. We gave a lift to a couple while the Managers did ???
The "main " guy spoke only on the morning we were leaving as they had trouble trying to get the Debit card to go through..Really rude and obviously don't care about the Staff or visitors. Does the owner know what goes on ? or do they come to life when there's a few more guests ?"
Even when I went to ask about a drink they never got up, just called a girl from the kitchen so we sat at one of the tables set for dinner and had an early night. They obviously ate later at the other table..Same thing on the second night after our trip out with David. He walks for 3 hrs. to be at work for 8am. and leaves at 5 pm. for his 3 hr. walk home ! Some of the girls also have over an hours walk to and from the camp. We gave a lift to a couple while the Managers did ???
The "main " guy spoke only on the morning we were leaving as they had trouble trying to get the Debit card to go through..Really rude and obviously don't care about the Staff or visitors. Does the owner know what goes on ? or do they come to life when there's a few more guests ?"
Average
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Average
Location
Good
Food
Average
Facilities
Average
Rooms
Good
Activities
Average
Feedback response
We put these comments to Lee, Camp Kwando’s manager, who appreciated the feedback, and apologised that these travellers felt that their stay was just ‘average’ – as he aims for much better.
Lee tells us that the team member who shows new guests to their rooms usually follows a ‘set procedure’ to explain to the guests their meal times, activities, and how the camp is run – and there’s always a chance for questions. He’s not sure why these travellers seem not to have had this, and hence why they didn’t know how the place worked. Whatever the reason, he’s sorry that this was the case.
He tells us that the management and staff here normally make a point of leaving the guests alone, without interrupting them. He’s sorry that these guests perceived their ‘hands-off’ approach to guests as being indifference – and assures us that this isn’t the case.
Lee explained to us that his team all have different duties – and that’s why a member of the bar staff was called from the kitchen to make a drink. The guide, Eli, introduced himself during dinner because one of his duties is to find out what activities each guest would like to do during the next day.
Lee was also sorry that these travellers felt that they didn’t have anywhere relaxing to sit. He commented that the camp usually accommodates up to 30 people, so there are a number of places to sit around the lodge. Our two travellers were the only people in camp at the time, and he’s sorry that they felt there was no space for them in the lounge. That said, he has discussed this with his team, and reminded them that they should vacate seats when guests come through.
Lee was appalled to learn that the guide, Eli, had smoked on an activity with guests; he agrees that this is totally unacceptable, and he has “dealt with it accordingly”.
Getting staff to camp for work can often be an issue in Africa. Lee explained to us that Camp Kwando doesn’t have the resources to provide transport to and from work for all of its staff, and that some, like the guide John (not David – there’s been a mix-up with names here), do live two hours’ walk away. They assure us that the situation is clear when people apply for jobs with the camp.
Lee told us that their policy was to lay on transport when it is raining heavily, or for any staff that work late – and that the small ‘night shift’ is always taken home after work. (In this case, for example, these travellers returned late to the lodge after their afternoon drive, and hence the manager drove John home.) We realise that such a long walk may seem (and probably is) difficult … but we’re pleased to hear that this lodge has a clear policy, which is broadly similar to many safari lodges.
Lee apologised if he, or anyone else in his team, seemed rude then these travellers checked out. He was disturbed by this comment, as he feels that he and his team do care about both their staff and guests alike. He was at pains to advise us that whilst Camp Kwando does aim to leave guests to themselves, he and his team aren’t unfriendly – and would always like to be viewed as approachable.
Lee tells us that the team member who shows new guests to their rooms usually follows a ‘set procedure’ to explain to the guests their meal times, activities, and how the camp is run – and there’s always a chance for questions. He’s not sure why these travellers seem not to have had this, and hence why they didn’t know how the place worked. Whatever the reason, he’s sorry that this was the case.
He tells us that the management and staff here normally make a point of leaving the guests alone, without interrupting them. He’s sorry that these guests perceived their ‘hands-off’ approach to guests as being indifference – and assures us that this isn’t the case.
Lee explained to us that his team all have different duties – and that’s why a member of the bar staff was called from the kitchen to make a drink. The guide, Eli, introduced himself during dinner because one of his duties is to find out what activities each guest would like to do during the next day.
Lee was also sorry that these travellers felt that they didn’t have anywhere relaxing to sit. He commented that the camp usually accommodates up to 30 people, so there are a number of places to sit around the lodge. Our two travellers were the only people in camp at the time, and he’s sorry that they felt there was no space for them in the lounge. That said, he has discussed this with his team, and reminded them that they should vacate seats when guests come through.
Lee was appalled to learn that the guide, Eli, had smoked on an activity with guests; he agrees that this is totally unacceptable, and he has “dealt with it accordingly”.
Getting staff to camp for work can often be an issue in Africa. Lee explained to us that Camp Kwando doesn’t have the resources to provide transport to and from work for all of its staff, and that some, like the guide John (not David – there’s been a mix-up with names here), do live two hours’ walk away. They assure us that the situation is clear when people apply for jobs with the camp.
Lee told us that their policy was to lay on transport when it is raining heavily, or for any staff that work late – and that the small ‘night shift’ is always taken home after work. (In this case, for example, these travellers returned late to the lodge after their afternoon drive, and hence the manager drove John home.) We realise that such a long walk may seem (and probably is) difficult … but we’re pleased to hear that this lodge has a clear policy, which is broadly similar to many safari lodges.
Lee apologised if he, or anyone else in his team, seemed rude then these travellers checked out. He was disturbed by this comment, as he feels that he and his team do care about both their staff and guests alike. He was at pains to advise us that whilst Camp Kwando does aim to leave guests to themselves, he and his team aren’t unfriendly – and would always like to be viewed as approachable.
Nkwazi Lodge, Namibia (this camp has since closed)
"Basically a campsite."
1 night
Arrived
17 Dec 2007
"The room was nice but the "lodge" is really a campsite. Lots of people, and not really our kind of place. I understand that the owners try to help the local children but we were actually asked by a waiter for a contribution to his education and if he could have our address and details in the U.K for if he came over. This was not anyone we had any contact or conversation with other than the normal questions about the menu etc. and it made us feel uncomfortable having to refuse.
We also were put off the food by the behaviour of other guests.. one almost sticking his nose in a dish of "stew" to find out what it was and a coulple who actually put back a spoon into a dish after tasting it..from the spoon. Maybe a bit TOO free and easy and "communal" . Nothing much to do, as there was nowhere interesting to walk."
We also were put off the food by the behaviour of other guests.. one almost sticking his nose in a dish of "stew" to find out what it was and a coulple who actually put back a spoon into a dish after tasting it..from the spoon. Maybe a bit TOO free and easy and "communal" . Nothing much to do, as there was nowhere interesting to walk."
Average
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Average
Rooms
Average
Food
Average
Facilities
Poor
Service
Average
Activities
Poor
Not currently featured by Expert Africa
Nhoma Camp
"Fantastic experience"
4 nights
Arrived
18 Dec 2007
"Great experience. Arno was a fantastic host and we learned a great deal. The bushmen..and women were really friendly and we enjoyed every minute with them.
All the hunting, gathering etc....and yet amazingly relaxing.
ARE YOU AWARE THE CONTACT TELEPHONE NUMBERS ARE NOT CORRECT... NO LONGER AT TSUMKWE...we finally called Wilderness from a garage to ask them to try and contact. .... Arno not concerned unless guests haven't arrived by 5pm."
All the hunting, gathering etc....and yet amazingly relaxing.
ARE YOU AWARE THE CONTACT TELEPHONE NUMBERS ARE NOT CORRECT... NO LONGER AT TSUMKWE...we finally called Wilderness from a garage to ask them to try and contact. .... Arno not concerned unless guests haven't arrived by 5pm."
Excellent
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Excellent
Location
Excellent
Service
Excellent
Activities
Excellent
Rooms
Good
Food
Good
Facilities
Good
Feedback response
Arno and Estelle informed us of the change of telephone number during this travellers trip, but unfortuantely after they had visited Nhoma Camp. Unfortunately this was too late for these travellers, but all information was updated in December to show the new number for any future travellers.
Mushara Lodge
"Not as good as previous visit. Pity."
1 night
Arrived
22 Dec 2007
"We stayed here 4 years ago and it was so convenient for Etosha, relaxing, good food etc.
The refurbishment is fine, but there is no atmosphere.. staff can never replace hosts..it doesn't work. People make a place
memorable, unless it is truely exceptional.
The restaurant ..although almost full was like a doctor's waiting room. Also a few people had upset stomaches and it was possibly due to the fact that food is put out to encourage the animals and birds.... Very cute to see them around the pool Maybe.. BUT..We went early for breakfast and there were squirrels eating the cereals..on the tables, everywhere. Then a couple of Hornbills helped themselves to bread etc.
They were shooed off when someone came out of the kitchen and it obviously happens every day !!"
The refurbishment is fine, but there is no atmosphere.. staff can never replace hosts..it doesn't work. People make a place
memorable, unless it is truely exceptional.
The restaurant ..although almost full was like a doctor's waiting room. Also a few people had upset stomaches and it was possibly due to the fact that food is put out to encourage the animals and birds.... Very cute to see them around the pool Maybe.. BUT..We went early for breakfast and there were squirrels eating the cereals..on the tables, everywhere. Then a couple of Hornbills helped themselves to bread etc.
They were shooed off when someone came out of the kitchen and it obviously happens every day !!"
Average
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Average
Location
Good
Service
Average
Facilities
Good
Rooms
Good
Food
Average
Feedback response
Marc Pampe, Mushara’s owner, replied that he used to spend 24/7 at the lodge, whereas now he’s only there for 12 hours a day. He’s trained up his staff, and handed them a lot of responsibility; he feels that most of his guests like this. He’s pleased that the lodge has changed this way over the last few years.
We are sorry that these travellers felt that Mushara lacked ambiance; they specifically asked to stay here because of their previous experience. Mushara has changed in the last four years; it’s now more like a smart, small hotel than an informal, personal lodge. This suits some, but not others. We’d usually have lengthy discussions with our travellers about the pro’s and con’s of where to stay – but in this case we didn’t discuss Mushara much; perhaps we should have.
These travellers report that other at the lodge had stomach upsets. Marc comments that nobody mentioned this to him or his staff. As this didn’t affect our travellers, it’s difficult for us to make any comments here.
We’re told by Marc that the lodge doesn’t put food out for birds or squirrels. In fact, both their check-in information sheet and also a note on each outside table urge guest not to feed the birds and squirrels. Unfortunately, many guests do still feed the animals – and hence the problem. Marc assures us that he’s looking at how to reinforce this message without harming the wildlife.
We are sorry that these travellers felt that Mushara lacked ambiance; they specifically asked to stay here because of their previous experience. Mushara has changed in the last four years; it’s now more like a smart, small hotel than an informal, personal lodge. This suits some, but not others. We’d usually have lengthy discussions with our travellers about the pro’s and con’s of where to stay – but in this case we didn’t discuss Mushara much; perhaps we should have.
These travellers report that other at the lodge had stomach upsets. Marc comments that nobody mentioned this to him or his staff. As this didn’t affect our travellers, it’s difficult for us to make any comments here.
We’re told by Marc that the lodge doesn’t put food out for birds or squirrels. In fact, both their check-in information sheet and also a note on each outside table urge guest not to feed the birds and squirrels. Unfortunately, many guests do still feed the animals – and hence the problem. Marc assures us that he’s looking at how to reinforce this message without harming the wildlife.
Eningu Clayhouse
"Eningu Clayhouse review"
1 night
Arrived
30 Dec 2007
"Kate is a great asset. We stayed 4 years ago and it was fine, but the food is now excellent and Kate is a wonderful host."
Good
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Good
Location
Good
Service
Excellent
Activities
Average
Rooms
Good
Food
Excellent
Facilities
Good
Zebra River Lodge
"Fantastic walks, good to be back."
4 nights
Arrived
31 Dec 2007
"Great hosts, excellent food, great walks and location."
Excellent
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Excellent
Location
Excellent
Service
Excellent
Activities
Excellent
Rooms
Good
Food
Excellent
Facilities
Good
Olive Grove
"Wouldn't stay anywhere else in Windhoek."
1 night
Arrived
4 Jan 2008
"Excellent food, great rooms, good service, convenient location, wonderful hosts with charming staff."
Excellent
Experience Report
Overall Rating:
Excellent
Location
Excellent
Service
Excellent
Facilities
Excellent
Rooms
Excellent
Food
Excellent
The Staff and girls in the kitchen were all great, and as we were the only guests we appreciated all their efforts.. under the circumstances. We found it very relaxing after our journey and a good place to stay on en route for a couple of days.
PLEASE NOTE THE GRADES BELOW [Ed: to the right here!] REFLECT RECENT SALE. eg. Facilities could be excellent when refurbished and the service was very good under the circumstances."